On Thursday, JPMorgan shifted its stance on Murphy USA (NYSE:MUSA), downgrading the stock from a Neutral to an Underweight rating, while simultaneously raising the price target to $435 from $415.
The adjustment comes as the investment firm assesses the company's strategic shift towards larger store formats and the acquisition of QuickChek, which is expected to introduce a higher-margin leg of growth.
Murphy USA, known for its focus on low-margin, high-volume fuel and tobacco sales, has been transitioning towards a model that offers a better mix of higher-margin non-tobacco merchandise.
This shift is largely attributed to its new store initiative (NTI) and raze and rebuild program. Additionally, Murphy USA's acquisition of QuickChek aims to bolster its food and beverage offerings, potentially enhancing overall profit margins.
While Murphy USA's legacy operations have recently been outperforming QuickChek, the overall industry has seen a recovery in volumes post-COVID, barring some persistent work-from-home trends. Murphy USA in particular has gained significantly from industry-wide increases in fuel margins, especially given its substantial exposure to fuel sales.
Despite these positive developments, JPMorgan notes that the market may be overestimating future fuel margins beyond what is considered sustainable in the long term, including Murphy USA's own target of approximately 34 cents per gallon by 2028. Furthermore, the firm's valuation on an enterprise value to next twelve months (NTM) EBITDA basis is currently more than two standard deviations above the company's historical median.
JPMorgan acknowledges Murphy USA's successful business model and its prospects for continued growth in ex-fuel margins. The company is also well-positioned to maintain market share, especially in inflationary conditions. However, the current valuation, when compared to both the company's historical performance and its peer group, including ATD, appears to be reaching unsustainable levels according to JPMorgan's analysis.
In other recent news, Murphy USA has announced an increase in its quarterly cash dividend to $0.45 per share, a 2.3% rise from the previous quarter. This development is part of the company's ongoing commitment to providing value to its investors.
Additionally, Murphy USA reported a record-breaking quarter with the highest retail fuel margin in the company's history. Despite this, the company noticed a slower growth rate in merchandise sales, particularly in discretionary categories.
Murphy USA has reaffirmed its commitment to its growth strategies, which include value pricing, increasing store productivity, and implementing digital initiatives. The company plans to open 47 new store locations and projects to spend at the upper end of the $400 million to $450 million range by 2024.
The firm aims to repurchase up to $1.5 billion of stock by 2028, underscoring its commitment to driving shareholder value. These recent developments provide investors with an insight into Murphy USA's strategies and future plans.
InvestingPro Insights
In light of JPMorgan's recent analysis of Murphy USA, InvestingPro data provides additional context to the company's financial health and market position. Murphy USA boasts a market capitalization of $10.56 billion and operates with a moderate level of debt, which supports its strategic initiatives like the acquisition of QuickChek. The company's P/E ratio stands at 20.66, reflecting investor expectations for future earnings growth, which is further underscored by a notable 53.23% one-year total return, demonstrating strong performance in the market.
InvestingPro Tips indicate that Murphy USA has raised its dividend for four consecutive years, signaling confidence in its financial stability and commitment to returning value to shareholders. With analysts predicting profitability this year and a profitable track record over the last twelve months, Murphy USA remains a prominent player in the Specialty Retail industry. While some analysts have revised their earnings downwards for the upcoming period, the company's stock generally trades with low price volatility, providing a degree of predictability for investors. For those interested in deeper analysis, InvestingPro offers additional tips on Murphy USA at https://www.investing.com/pro/MUSA.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.