On Tuesday, Miniso (NYSE:MNSO) received a downgrade from JPMorgan from Overweight to Neutral, with a significant reduction in the price target to $15.00, a sharp decrease from the previous $27.00. The adjustment followed Miniso's unexpected move to acquire a 29.4% stake in Yonghui Superstores, which analysts believe negatively surprised the market. Despite the market's reaction, which saw Miniso's shares plunge by 24% on the day of the announcement, JPMorgan maintains a positive outlook on Miniso's core business, which focuses on intellectual property, overseas expansion, and execution capabilities.
The downgrade is a response to concerns regarding the strategic fit between Miniso's global intellectual property business model and the domestic grocery store chain it intends to invest in. Analysts at JPMorgan have expressed skepticism about the potential for meaningful operating leverage between the two entities. Additionally, the firm has highlighted issues with decreasing visibility and credibility related to management philosophy and corporate governance at Miniso, which they believe do not support a long-term holding position.
JPMorgan's new price target implies a 10x price-to-earnings ratio for the year 2025 and suggests a 9-15% upside. However, they caution that while some investors might consider buying shares at current levels for short-term gains, the uncertainties surrounding the company's direction and governance may deter long-term investment. The 44% reduction in Miniso's price target to $15.00 reflects several factors, including a 22% increase in the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) from 13.9% to 17.4%, an 11% reduction in deal-related funding costs, and an 11% decrease to account for the anticipated slower growth of Miniso's core business from 2025 to 2030 due to the dilution of internal financial and management resources related to the deal.
In other recent news, Miniso Group Holding Limited has announced its plans to acquire a 29.4% stake in Yonghui Superstores, making it the largest shareholder. This move is part of Miniso's recent strategic developments, which have drawn attention from financial analysts. BofA Securities and Jefferies have both downgraded Miniso's stock rating due to concerns about the acquisition and potential risks it may pose.
BofA Securities moved from Buy to Underperform, while Jefferies downgraded from Buy to Hold. Both firms cite uncertainties and potential risks linked to the acquisition, questioning the synergies between Miniso's value retail model and Yonghui's food and beverage focus. Despite these concerns, Miniso's CEO, Guofu Ye, remains confident in the growth potential of the deal, anticipating shared resources and enhanced economies of scale. The acquisition is expected to be completed in the first half of 2025, pending regulatory approvals.
InvestingPro Insights
Amidst the recent downgrade by JPMorgan, Miniso (NYSE:MNSO) showcases some financial strengths and challenges that investors should consider. InvestingPro data indicates that the company holds a market capitalization of approximately $4.17 billion, with a P/E ratio standing at 13.34. This valuation metric suggests a level of investor confidence in the company's earnings ability, relative to its current share price. Additionally, Miniso has demonstrated robust revenue growth over the last twelve months as of Q2 2024, with an impressive increase of 39.43%, signaling strong sales performance.
Despite the recent stock price volatility, with a one-week total return of -10.33% and a three-month total return of -29.91%, Miniso's financials reveal a company that has been profitable over the last year. This is further supported by a noteworthy gross profit margin of 41.18%, indicating efficient cost management relative to sales. Furthermore, the company's dividend yield stands at 3.85%, with Miniso having raised its dividend for four consecutive years—an InvestingPro Tip that may appeal to income-focused investors.
For those considering Miniso's future prospects, it is worth noting that the company has more cash than debt on its balance sheet and cash flows can sufficiently cover interest payments, which speaks to its financial stability. Moreover, Miniso is recognized as a prominent player in the Broadline Retail industry, which could be a key factor in its resilience and growth potential. For investors seeking deeper analysis and additional insights, InvestingPro offers further tips on Miniso, available at: https://www.investing.com/pro/MNSO
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.