On Thursday, Evercore ISI updated its price target on CarMax (NYSE:KMX) shares, lifting it to $79.00 from the previous $76.00 while maintaining an In Line rating. The firm highlighted CarMax's efforts to enhance its customer experience as a key driver for future share gains, margin leverage, and profitable alternative revenue streams.
According to the firm, CarMax's focus on improving speed and efficiency through an omnichannel approach is expected to be beneficial in the long term.
The firm noted that although CarMax has faced challenges over the past two years, including issues with affordability and market share, there are signs that these issues are stabilizing. In the most recent quarter, CarMax reported a reduction in retail car prices by more than 5% or $1,000, which was seen as a move to support consumers facing financial pressures.
Evercore ISI pointed out that CarMax had experienced additional volatility in car prices since 2021, which was exacerbated by the company's strategy to maintain prices while competitors took more aggressive pricing actions. This resulted in CarMax losing some market share as it prioritized maximizing gross profit dollars over sales volume.
The firm's Base Case target of $79.00 is based on approximately 17 times the normalized earnings per share (EPS) of around $5.50, discounted back. This price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is considered above average, reflecting the firm's view that the current results are cyclically depressed and may improve in the future.
The analyst concluded by acknowledging the current uncertain consumer environment, credit trends, and affordability issues, which have led to a cautious stance in the near term. Despite this, Evercore ISI's revised price target reflects optimism about CarMax's strategic initiatives and potential for recovery.
In other recent news, CarMax has been the focus of several significant developments. The company reported a 13% increase in earnings for the August quarter at $0.85 per share, despite a slight decrease of 0.9% in net sales, which totalled $7.01 billion.
CarMax also saw a 4.3% increase in comparable retail unit sales, exceeding the expected 3.0%, according to Truist Securities. Additionally, Baird maintained an Outperform rating for the company, citing advancements in sourcing and credit initiatives.
However, a challenging credit environment has led to a substantial miss in CarMax's CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) segment. Analysts from various firms, including Needham, RBC Capital Markets, and Evercore ISI, have adjusted their price targets for CarMax, citing factors such as strong second-quarter results and concerns over higher loan losses potentially leading to tighter credit conditions.
In response to these developments, CarMax is testing new credit scoring models and planning to centralize logistics operations. These recent changes demonstrate the company's ongoing efforts to navigate current market conditions and improve its business model.
InvestingPro Insights
To complement Evercore ISI's analysis, recent data from InvestingPro offers additional context on CarMax's financial position and market performance. The company's market capitalization stands at $11.59 billion, with a P/E ratio of 28.28, indicating that investors are willing to pay a premium for CarMax's earnings despite recent challenges.
InvestingPro Tips highlight that CarMax is a prominent player in the Specialty Retail industry, which aligns with Evercore ISI's focus on the company's customer experience improvements. However, the company currently suffers from weak gross profit margins, which is reflected in the latest data showing a gross profit margin of 11.96% for the last twelve months.
On a positive note, CarMax's liquid assets exceed short-term obligations, suggesting financial stability in the near term. This could provide the company with the flexibility to continue investing in its omnichannel approach and customer experience enhancements, as mentioned in the Evercore ISI analysis.
It's worth noting that InvestingPro offers 11 additional tips for CarMax, providing investors with a more comprehensive view of the company's prospects. These insights can be particularly valuable given the uncertain consumer environment and affordability issues highlighted in the article.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.