Why is it up for debate about whether a trend exists in markets and if it does the direction? Shouldn’t these things be clear cut or at least defined by rules? On the surface the answer to why there are opinions about the same data can be attributed to differences in timeframe. An investor that has a long horizon will not see the bumps in the road that a short term trader will. But that does not explain why there are differences of opinion at major turning points.
The biggest turning point in recent history was the March 2009 low. And even giving the benefit of the doubt to some longer term investors, there was still debate about if an uptrend was in play years later. Doesn’t this seem insane? There has to be more than timeframe involved.
Fast forward to late August 2015. In the chart below is the daily activity for the iShares Russell 2000 (NYSE:IWM). It made a low on August 24th. Then it moved higher to August 31st. Next a move lower to September 1st. This made a higher low. The next move was to a higher high on September 9th. Following came a higher low on the 11th and now Wednesday a higher high.
A series of higher lows and higher highs defines an uptrend. So why are there no prognosticators spewing forth that a new uptrend has begun? Well again we can give the long term investors a pass for now as these are just short term data. But the loud crowd are the short term traders and even day traders. And for them this should be seen as an uptrend.
The best answer I can come up with is that traders and investors are human. They cannot, try as they might, separate the pure data from the emotion. In the case of March 2009 it was the fear and panic of a 40% pullback. Three weeks ago it was the fear of a 10% pullback. There has been memory created by these moves lower and they will not be soon forgotten.
This plays a role in the itchy trigger finger responses at the first sign of weakness. How soon until it goes away? I have no idea. But the important piece of information to take away from this is that it exists. Know that as you trade or invest there are memories of deep losses that cloud your and others thoughts.
The information in this blog post represents my own opinions and does not contain a recommendation for any particular security or investment. I or my affiliates may hold positions or other interests in securities mentioned in the Blog, please see my Disclaimer page for my full disclaimer.