On Monday, Telsey Advisory Group adjusted its stance on Five Below (NASDAQ:FIVE), a popular discount retailer, by downgrading the stock from Outperform to Market Perform and reducing the price target to $95 from the previous $102. The firm cited several factors contributing to the downgrade, including a major strategic transition within the company, leadership changes, and potential tariff-related pressures that obscure the outlook for the retailer's near- to medium-term performance.
Five Below has been navigating significant internal shifts, including the search for a permanent CEO following the promotion of Ken Bull to Interim CEO on July 16, after Joel Anderson departed to become the CEO of Petco. Additionally, Andy Kunselman was promoted to replace the retiring Chief Merchant Michael Romanko on November 17, 2024.
In terms of expansion, Five Below has decided to slow down its new store openings, planning for 150-180 new locations in 2025, a decrease from approximately 230 in 2024. This represents a unit growth of 8.5%-10.0%, compared to the mid-teens growth rate in the prior year, with the company's longer-term expansion plans remaining unclear.
Merchandising is another area where Five Below is recalibrating its strategy. After previously breaking its $5 price point in response to tariffs, the company is now focusing on revamping its value proposition. Efforts include increasing the number of items priced between $1 and $5, simplifying price points, and enhancing product value to win back its core demographic of teens and tweens. The impact of these merchandising changes is expected to become more apparent in the second half of 2025.
The company's Five Beyond format is also under review, with plans to adjust the layout and assortment to better resonate with consumers. Additionally, Five Below is transitioning to an associate-monitored self-checkout process, moving away from the previous system where associates assisted with checkout as needed.
While Telsey acknowledges that these initiatives are generally moving in the right direction, the firm also recognizes that the changes could lead to disruptions over the coming quarters. The ongoing uncertainty around tariffs is noted as a factor that may further complicate the company's trajectory in 2025 and beyond.
In other recent news, Five Below reported a decrease in net income despite a 9.4% increase in total sales, reaching $830 million. However, comparable store sales declined by 5.7%. Gordon Haskett upgraded Five Below from Hold to Buy, setting a new price target of $120, citing a potential 35% upside from current stock levels. This upgrade was made despite recent downgrades by other analysts over tariff-related concerns.
On the contrary, BofA Securities downgraded Five Below from Neutral to Underperform and reduced its price target to $75, citing concerns over the company's ability to recover in its comparable store sales and expectations for continued margin pressure.
Meanwhile, Mizuho (NYSE:MFG) Securities increased the price target on Five Below's shares to $90, maintaining a neutral rating, while Craig-Hallum raised its stock price target to $125 from the previous $102, maintaining a buy rating.
Five Below announced plans to open between 150 to 180 new stores in 2025 as part of a strategic shift to improve operational efficiency and re-engage with its core customers. These are the recent developments for Five Below.
InvestingPro Insights
To complement the analysis provided by Telsey Advisory Group, recent data from InvestingPro offers additional context to Five Below's current situation. The company's market capitalization stands at $4.78 billion, with a P/E ratio of 16.9, reflecting the market's current valuation of the stock relative to its earnings.
InvestingPro Tips highlight that Five Below's stock price has fallen significantly over the last year, with a 54.49% decline in the one-year price total return. This aligns with Telsey's more cautious stance on the company. Despite these challenges, InvestingPro Tips also indicate that Five Below remains profitable over the last twelve months and analysts predict continued profitability this year.
The company's revenue growth of 14.23% over the last twelve months suggests that despite the strategic shifts and leadership changes, Five Below has maintained its ability to grow sales. However, the PEG ratio of 3.84 indicates that the stock may be trading at a high P/E ratio relative to its near-term earnings growth potential, which could support Telsey's decision to downgrade the stock.
For investors seeking a more comprehensive analysis, InvestingPro offers additional tips and insights that could provide further clarity on Five Below's financial health and market position.
This article was generated with the support of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more information see our T&C.